{
  "schema": "GrainGrowth2D.StatisticalValidationStudy/1",
  "release": "1.5.0",
  "title": "Statistical validation of normal grain growth: size distribution and topology against published 2D statistics",
  "configuration": {
    "alloy": "Cu-Zn",
    "temperature_K": 973,
    "grid": [
      512,
      512
    ],
    "boundary": "periodic",
    "neighborhood": 8,
    "kT_MC": 0.52708559046587211,
    "MCS": 2000,
    "initialNuclei": 4096,
    "seeds": [
      7,
      13,
      29
    ],
    "outputInterval_MCS": 5,
    "umPerCell": 1.9940105822687053,
    "study": "Validation/ExecutedBinaryStudies/CuZn_GrowthLaw (same configuration, 973 K)"
  },
  "grainDefinition": "Connected component of equal grain state, four-connected (gg2d.components); R = sqrt(A/pi) from the area in sites; x = R/<R> per frame; every grain counted, no size cut-off. The domain is periodic, so no grain touches a border and none is excluded.",
  "sidesDefinition": "n = number of distinct neighbouring grains sharing a lattice edge (gg2d.stateTopology); corner-only (diagonal) contacts are not neighbours; with them n is reported separately.",
  "frames": {
    "frameMCS": [
      250,
      255,
      260,
      500,
      505,
      510,
      750,
      755,
      760,
      1000,
      1005,
      1010,
      1250,
      1255,
      1260,
      1500,
      1505,
      1510,
      1750,
      1755,
      1760,
      1990,
      1995,
      2000
    ],
    "lateTimes": [
      500,
      1000,
      1500,
      2000
    ],
    "pairStarts": [
      250,
      500,
      750,
      1000,
      1250,
      1500,
      1750,
      1990
    ],
    "intervals": [
      5,
      10
    ]
  },
  "reproduction": {
    "perSeed": [
      {
        "seed": 7,
        "commonMCS": 101,
        "maxAbsGrainCount": 0,
        "maxAbsMeanECD_cells": 4.9737991503207013E-14,
        "maxAbsRMSECD_cells": 4.9737991503207013E-14,
        "interceptMCS": [
          260,
          500,
          760,
          1000,
          1260,
          1500,
          1760,
          2000
        ],
        "maxAbsLinealIntercept_cells": 4.2632564145606011E-14
      },
      {
        "seed": 13,
        "commonMCS": 101,
        "maxAbsGrainCount": 0,
        "maxAbsMeanECD_cells": 4.9737991503207013E-14,
        "maxAbsRMSECD_cells": 4.9737991503207013E-14,
        "interceptMCS": [
          260,
          500,
          760,
          1000,
          1260,
          1500,
          1760,
          2000
        ],
        "maxAbsLinealIntercept_cells": 4.9737991503207013E-14
      },
      {
        "seed": 29,
        "commonMCS": 101,
        "maxAbsGrainCount": 0,
        "maxAbsMeanECD_cells": 4.9737991503207013E-14,
        "maxAbsRMSECD_cells": 4.9737991503207013E-14,
        "interceptMCS": [
          260,
          500,
          760,
          1000,
          1260,
          1500,
          1760,
          2000
        ],
        "maxAbsLinealIntercept_cells": 3.3750779948604759E-14
      }
    ],
    "reproduced": true,
    "rule": "Grain count, number-mean and RMS ECD at every MCS common to the re-run and Validation/ExecutedBinaryStudies/CuZn_GrowthLaw/trajectories.csv (every 20 MCS), and the mean lineal intercept at the stored frames on that grid; reproduced when the counts are equal and the lengths agree to 1e-9 cells."
  },
  "grainCounts": [
    {
      "Seed": 7,
      "MCS": 500,
      "Grains": 1899
    },
    {
      "Seed": 7,
      "MCS": 1000,
      "Grains": 1214
    },
    {
      "Seed": 7,
      "MCS": 1500,
      "Grains": 878
    },
    {
      "Seed": 7,
      "MCS": 2000,
      "Grains": 659
    },
    {
      "Seed": 13,
      "MCS": 500,
      "Grains": 1905
    },
    {
      "Seed": 13,
      "MCS": 1000,
      "Grains": 1153
    },
    {
      "Seed": 13,
      "MCS": 1500,
      "Grains": 845
    },
    {
      "Seed": 13,
      "MCS": 2000,
      "Grains": 660
    },
    {
      "Seed": 29,
      "MCS": 500,
      "Grains": 1919
    },
    {
      "Seed": 29,
      "MCS": 1000,
      "Grains": 1184
    },
    {
      "Seed": 29,
      "MCS": 1500,
      "Grains": 851
    },
    {
      "Seed": 29,
      "MCS": 2000,
      "Grains": 655
    }
  ],
  "selfSimilarity": {
    "seeds": [
      7,
      13,
      29
    ],
    "times": [
      500,
      1000,
      1500,
      2000
    ],
    "perTime": [
      {
        "MCS": 500,
        "Grains": 5723,
        "DeltaT_seedToSeed": 0.054241455450437105,
        "LognormalMu": -0.10812830238000479,
        "LognormalSigma": 0.529584406710899,
        "WeibullAlpha": 1.1207235487558835,
        "WeibullBeta": 2.7499816274884581
      },
      {
        "MCS": 1000,
        "Grains": 3551,
        "DeltaT_seedToSeed": 0.089055429500579389,
        "LognormalMu": -0.11753705914302118,
        "LognormalSigma": 0.55561569766550123,
        "WeibullAlpha": 1.1223574591591288,
        "WeibullBeta": 2.6138388637816585
      },
      {
        "MCS": 1500,
        "Grains": 2574,
        "DeltaT_seedToSeed": 0.080443726980017269,
        "LognormalMu": -0.12905413466012813,
        "LognormalSigma": 0.58768465584718321,
        "WeibullAlpha": 1.1230770306674147,
        "WeibullBeta": 2.5020685770821744
      },
      {
        "MCS": 2000,
        "Grains": 1974,
        "DeltaT_seedToSeed": 0.079307373682380944,
        "LognormalMu": -0.12964979582972361,
        "LognormalSigma": 0.594480287279613,
        "WeibullAlpha": 1.122285935845371,
        "WeibullBeta": 2.518949901089913
      }
    ],
    "pairs": [
      {
        "MCS1": 500,
        "MCS2": 1000,
        "DeltaT_pooledSeeds": 0.052779909117896796,
        "DeltaT_crossSeed": 0.083000355177142091,
        "DeltaT_noise": 0.089055429500579389,
        "WithinNoise": true,
        "DeltaT_lognormalFits": 0.023960662896975581,
        "DeltaT_weibullFits": 0.023654505941985225
      },
      {
        "MCS1": 500,
        "MCS2": 1500,
        "DeltaT_pooledSeeds": 0.06228517245466398,
        "DeltaT_crossSeed": 0.081407422538340768,
        "DeltaT_noise": 0.080443726980017269,
        "WithinNoise": false,
        "DeltaT_lognormalFits": 0.051917026053597243,
        "DeltaT_weibullFits": 0.043898091027572243
      },
      {
        "MCS1": 500,
        "MCS2": 2000,
        "DeltaT_pooledSeeds": 0.057326052946561457,
        "DeltaT_crossSeed": 0.077557366363094959,
        "DeltaT_noise": 0.079307373682380944,
        "WithinNoise": true,
        "DeltaT_lognormalFits": 0.057361582051033255,
        "DeltaT_weibullFits": 0.040706688187415789
      },
      {
        "MCS1": 1000,
        "MCS2": 1500,
        "DeltaT_pooledSeeds": 0.042612398709272831,
        "DeltaT_crossSeed": 0.078997659489527791,
        "DeltaT_noise": 0.089055429500579389,
        "WithinNoise": true,
        "DeltaT_lognormalFits": 0.027994947330225933,
        "DeltaT_weibullFits": 0.020273265754596485
      },
      {
        "MCS1": 1000,
        "MCS2": 2000,
        "DeltaT_pooledSeeds": 0.041642592793901687,
        "DeltaT_crossSeed": 0.080026866945932584,
        "DeltaT_noise": 0.089055429500579389,
        "WithinNoise": true,
        "DeltaT_lognormalFits": 0.0334658778496915,
        "DeltaT_weibullFits": 0.017089469152708849
      },
      {
        "MCS1": 1500,
        "MCS2": 2000,
        "DeltaT_pooledSeeds": 0.042657106486893727,
        "DeltaT_crossSeed": 0.08084833250680333,
        "DeltaT_noise": 0.080443726980017269,
        "WithinNoise": false,
        "DeltaT_lognormalFits": 0.0055667486664307386,
        "DeltaT_weibullFits": 0.0032265441170277118
      }
    ],
    "timeInvariant": false,
    "pooledTimes": 2000,
    "pooledIndex": 4,
    "binWidth": 0.1,
    "rule": "delta_T from bin probabilities, bins of width 0.1 on x from 0 to 3.5 and one bin above. Noise at a time = mean delta_T between the single-seed samples of that time (3 pairs). Two times are within noise when the mean delta_T between single-seed samples of different seeds at the two times (6 pairs) does not exceed the larger noise of the two times. Pooled late regime: the latest time and each earlier time, going back, within noise of every later member. DeltaT_lognormalFits and DeltaT_weibullFits compare the curves fitted at the two times (seeds pooled), the measure of S-STAT-2017 Appendix II."
  },
  "referenceComparison": {
    "grains": 1974,
    "frames": 3,
    "comparisons": [
      {
        "Reference": "lognormal_experiment",
        "Label": "Lognormal, thin-film experiment (\\sigma = 0.5, \\mu = -0.12)",
        "Source": "S-STAT-2017 eq. (1), p. 1; Fig. 1 caption, p. 2",
        "DeltaT": 0.18902953246195373,
        "ReferenceMean": 1.0050055275942367
      },
      {
        "Reference": "hillert",
        "Label": "Hillert 2D",
        "Source": "S-STAT-2017 eq. (2), p. 2",
        "DeltaT": 0.14874580633344384,
        "ReferenceMean": 1.0000000000000004
      },
      {
        "Reference": "rayleigh",
        "Label": "Rayleigh (\\alpha = 1.030, \\beta = 2)",
        "Source": "S-STAT-2017 eq. (3), p. 2; Fig. 1 caption, p. 2",
        "DeltaT": 0.15742968550510378,
        "ReferenceMean": 0.912813733216341
      },
      {
        "Reference": "weibull",
        "Label": "Weibull (\\alpha = 1.001, \\beta = 2.367)",
        "Source": "S-STAT-2017 eq. (3), p. 2; Fig. 1 caption, p. 2",
        "DeltaT": 0.14727797083158681,
        "ReferenceMean": 0.88715466407016652
      },
      {
        "Reference": "normal_mullins",
        "Label": "Normal, Mullins model (mean 1.00, s.d. 0.38)",
        "Source": "S-STAT-2019 Table 1, p. 7",
        "DeltaT": 0.092608837899314331,
        "ReferenceMean": 1.0005028446832867
      }
    ],
    "closest": "normal_mullins",
    "samplingFloor": {
      "mean": 0.037978723404255323,
      "p95": 0.048632218844984809,
      "rule": "200 bootstrap resamples of the pooled sample (stream mt19937ar, seed 1): delta_T between each resample and the sample."
    },
    "fits": {
      "lognormal": {
        "mu": -0.12964979582972361,
        "sigma": 0.594480287279613,
        "muCI95": [
          -0.15587458316299141,
          -0.10342500849645579
        ],
        "sigmaCI95": [
          0.57593186354362169,
          0.6130287110156043
        ],
        "n": 1974
      },
      "weibull": {
        "alpha": 1.122285935845371,
        "beta": 2.518949901089913,
        "alphaCI95": [
          1.1015912586628833,
          1.1429806130278586
        ],
        "betaCI95": [
          2.4323096306291419,
          2.6055901715506842
        ],
        "n": 1974
      },
      "normal": {
        "mean": 1.0000000000000002,
        "sd": 0.42184796019386761,
        "meanCI95": [
          0.98139068144095842,
          1.0186093185590421
        ],
        "sdCI95": [
          0.40868585055749007,
          0.43501006983024515
        ],
        "n": 1974
      }
    },
    "closerToWeibullThanExperiment": true,
    "tails": {
      "smallBelow_x": 0.5,
      "largeAbove_x": 2,
      "simulationSmall": 0.13272543059777103,
      "simulationLarge": 0.0040526849037487338,
      "experimentSmall": 0.1258366876651747,
      "experimentLarge": 0.051943525384004485,
      "fewerSmallAndLarge": false
    }
  },
  "topology": {
    "grains": 1974,
    "meanSides": 5.9685916919959476,
    "variance": 2.1357916336898413,
    "mu2": 2.13677811550152,
    "mode": 5,
    "meanSidesWithCorners": 5.9969604863221884,
    "varianceWithCorners": 2.064833719816582,
    "mu2WithCorners": 2.06484295845998,
    "modeWithCorners": 5,
    "grainsWithAtMostTwoSides": 28,
    "aboavWeaire": {
      "classes": [
        3,
        4,
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8,
        9
      ],
      "meanRelDev_mu2": 0.010042141300248244,
      "maxRelDev_mu2": 0.024343142406726529,
      "meanRelDev_5plus8overN": 0.00929892067831235,
      "maxRelDev_5plus8overN": 0.030434782608696011,
      "grainsWithInteriorNeighbours": 1974
    },
    "perimeterRule": {
      "classes": [
        3,
        4,
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8,
        9
      ],
      "meanAbsDev": 0.035326758940474719,
      "meanSignedDev": -0.0031179639998527059
    },
    "classes": [
      {
        "Sides": 2,
        "Count": 28,
        "Fraction": 0.014184397163120567,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 7.8392857142857144,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 9.06838905775076,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 9,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 0.061619558144275548,
        "PerimeterRule": 0,
        "AtLeast30": false
      },
      {
        "Sides": 3,
        "Count": 30,
        "Fraction": 0.015197568389057751,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 7.9000000000000021,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 7.71225937183384,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 7.6666666666666661,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 0.23345752903481895,
        "PerimeterRule": 0.25,
        "AtLeast30": true
      },
      {
        "Sides": 4,
        "Count": 174,
        "Fraction": 0.088145896656534953,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 7.1408045977011492,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 7.03419452887538,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 7,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 0.47972556671766925,
        "PerimeterRule": 0.5,
        "AtLeast30": true
      },
      {
        "Sides": 5,
        "Count": 560,
        "Fraction": 0.28368794326241137,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 6.5785714285714292,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 6.6273556231003043,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 6.6,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 0.72925006429251427,
        "PerimeterRule": 0.75,
        "AtLeast30": true
      },
      {
        "Sides": 6,
        "Count": 542,
        "Fraction": 0.27456940222897669,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 6.31211562115621,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 6.35612968591692,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 6.333333333333333,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 1.0361299238506294,
        "PerimeterRule": 1,
        "AtLeast30": true
      },
      {
        "Sides": 7,
        "Count": 376,
        "Fraction": 0.19047619047619047,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 6.1306990881458976,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 6.1623968736430745,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 6.1428571428571423,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 1.3012292530174163,
        "PerimeterRule": 1.25,
        "AtLeast30": true
      },
      {
        "Sides": 8,
        "Count": 158,
        "Fraction": 0.0800405268490375,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 5.9928797468354427,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 6.01709726443769,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 6,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 1.5253716054241313,
        "PerimeterRule": 1.5,
        "AtLeast30": true
      },
      {
        "Sides": 9,
        "Count": 75,
        "Fraction": 0.037993920972644375,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 5.8607407407407406,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 5.9040864572779466,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 5.8888888888888893,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 1.6730103096638516,
        "PerimeterRule": 1.75,
        "AtLeast30": true
      },
      {
        "Sides": 10,
        "Count": 25,
        "Fraction": 0.012664640324214792,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 5.7280000000000006,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 5.8136778115501517,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 5.8,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 1.8205100585984995,
        "PerimeterRule": 2,
        "AtLeast30": false
      },
      {
        "Sides": 11,
        "Count": 5,
        "Fraction": 0.0025329280648429585,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 5.6181818181818182,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 5.7397071014092287,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 5.7272727272727275,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 1.7511356808563463,
        "PerimeterRule": 2.25,
        "AtLeast30": false
      },
      {
        "Sides": 12,
        "Count": 1,
        "Fraction": 0.00050658561296859173,
        "MeanNeighbourSides": 5.25,
        "AboavWeaire_mu2": 5.67806484295846,
        "AboavWeaire_5plus8overN": 5.666666666666667,
        "MeanReducedRadius": 1.8211072755978615,
        "PerimeterRule": 2.5,
        "AtLeast30": false
      }
    ],
    "cornerClasses": [
      {
        "Sides": 2,
        "Count": 6
      },
      {
        "Sides": 3,
        "Count": 47
      },
      {
        "Sides": 4,
        "Count": 175
      },
      {
        "Sides": 5,
        "Count": 557
      },
      {
        "Sides": 6,
        "Count": 544
      },
      {
        "Sides": 7,
        "Count": 373
      },
      {
        "Sides": 8,
        "Count": 162
      },
      {
        "Sides": 9,
        "Count": 78
      },
      {
        "Sides": 10,
        "Count": 26
      },
      {
        "Sides": 11,
        "Count": 5
      },
      {
        "Sides": 12,
        "Count": 1
      }
    ]
  },
  "vonNeumannMullins": [
    {
      "interval_MCS": 5,
      "grains": 31675,
      "matchedByLabel": 30238,
      "matchedByOverlap": 880,
      "vanished": 499,
      "merged": 58,
      "classes": [
        {
          "Sides": 1,
          "Count": 17,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.14117647058823529,
          "StandardError": 0.022782254977690687,
          "InFit": false
        },
        {
          "Sides": 2,
          "Count": 419,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.1747016706443911,
          "StandardError": 0.0042286765958250584,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 3,
          "Count": 539,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.42931354359925794,
          "StandardError": 0.018656894024465097,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 4,
          "Count": 3236,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.30883807169344885,
          "StandardError": 0.0098691400929075742,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 5,
          "Count": 8206,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.15771386790153546,
          "StandardError": 0.0072975365203130273,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 6,
          "Count": 8945,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.0020793739519284525,
          "StandardError": 0.0083400521080883236,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 7,
          "Count": 5932,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.15421443020903569,
          "StandardError": 0.011184569545745073,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 8,
          "Count": 2923,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.29846048580225781,
          "StandardError": 0.017213513118432777,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 9,
          "Count": 1052,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.49828897338403022,
          "StandardError": 0.031062742072582548,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 10,
          "Count": 313,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.5182108626198082,
          "StandardError": 0.056536583298929979,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 11,
          "Count": 75,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.62933333333333341,
          "StandardError": 0.12890073467362162,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 12,
          "Count": 12,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.63333333333333341,
          "StandardError": 0.23847156406726333,
          "InFit": false
        },
        {
          "Sides": 13,
          "Count": 5,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 1.44,
          "StandardError": 0.74672618810377878,
          "InFit": false
        },
        {
          "Sides": 14,
          "Count": 1,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 1,
          "StandardError": 0,
          "InFit": false
        }
      ],
      "fitClasses": [
        2,
        3,
        4,
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8,
        9,
        10,
        11
      ],
      "slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.11775416951510743,
      "intercept_sitesPerMCS": -0.66281594609240824,
      "zeroCrossing": 5.6288108422977867,
      "rSquared": 0.91107285352218059,
      "mobility_sitesPerMCS": 0.11244694888806193,
      "perStartSlope": [
        {
          "StartMCS": 250,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.1297685995424735
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 500,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.1173909024312652
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 750,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.10226040089900625
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1000,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.12482183958519583
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1250,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.12422693843111232
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1500,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.16657247725877439
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1750,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.16948697394137269
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1990,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.099812656265827485
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "interval_MCS": 10,
      "grains": 31675,
      "matchedByLabel": 30062,
      "matchedByOverlap": 850,
      "vanished": 715,
      "merged": 48,
      "classes": [
        {
          "Sides": 1,
          "Count": 17,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.10000000000000002,
          "StandardError": 3.4694469519536142E-18,
          "InFit": false
        },
        {
          "Sides": 2,
          "Count": 419,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.10310262529832916,
          "StandardError": 0.0026022024080330718,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 3,
          "Count": 539,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.36920222634508348,
          "StandardError": 0.012607006510662247,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 4,
          "Count": 3236,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.31786155747836842,
          "StandardError": 0.0067475823819633535,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 5,
          "Count": 8206,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.15374116500121857,
          "StandardError": 0.0051742458644370376,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 6,
          "Count": 8945,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.0007043040804918944,
          "StandardError": 0.0057794780054419128,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 7,
          "Count": 5932,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.14762306136210382,
          "StandardError": 0.0079335770175805315,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 8,
          "Count": 2923,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.29914471433458761,
          "StandardError": 0.012185810061086226,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 9,
          "Count": 1052,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.47043726235741445,
          "StandardError": 0.02150216554690064,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 10,
          "Count": 313,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.56517571884984041,
          "StandardError": 0.042352681674650013,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 11,
          "Count": 75,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.62666666666666671,
          "StandardError": 0.089005179185943556,
          "InFit": true
        },
        {
          "Sides": 12,
          "Count": 12,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 0.79999999999999982,
          "StandardError": 0.15175738212786563,
          "InFit": false
        },
        {
          "Sides": 13,
          "Count": 5,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": 1.06,
          "StandardError": 0.54369108876272743,
          "InFit": false
        },
        {
          "Sides": 14,
          "Count": 1,
          "MeanRate_sitesPerMCS": -0.5,
          "StandardError": 0,
          "InFit": false
        }
      ],
      "fitClasses": [
        2,
        3,
        4,
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8,
        9,
        10,
        11
      ],
      "slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.11245842265768108,
      "intercept_sitesPerMCS": -0.61439533192211671,
      "zeroCrossing": 5.4633109499704737,
      "rSquared": 0.88389637107922459,
      "mobility_sitesPerMCS": 0.10738988314972528,
      "perStartSlope": [
        {
          "StartMCS": 250,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.11215032769294249
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 500,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.1098237652996327
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 750,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.097739768353015122
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1000,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.12241780987859815
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1250,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.11068056451525608
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1500,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.15267185974510422
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1750,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.14926714782599182
        },
        {
          "StartMCS": 1990,
          "Slope_sitesPerMCS": 0.11517014046071823
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "measuredMaps": [
    {
      "sample": "nickel",
      "suitable": true,
      "reason": "meets the three criteria",
      "interiorGrains": 1250,
      "deltaT_toSimulation": 0.24480729483282682
    },
    {
      "sample": "aluminium",
      "suitable": false,
      "reason": "fewer than 300 interior grains (211)",
      "interiorGrains": 211,
      "deltaT_toSimulation": null
    },
    {
      "sample": "titanium",
      "suitable": false,
      "reason": "fewer than 300 interior grains (48)",
      "interiorGrains": 48,
      "deltaT_toSimulation": null
    },
    {
      "sample": "Inconel 718",
      "suitable": false,
      "reason": "non-equiaxed (mean aspect ratio 2.14)",
      "interiorGrains": 395,
      "deltaT_toSimulation": null
    }
  ],
  "sourceValues": [
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Lognormal density of x",
      "value": "p(x) = 1/(x sigma sqrt(2 pi)) exp{-[ln(x) - mu]^2/(2 sigma^2)}",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "eq. (1), p. 1",
      "note": "x = linear grain size evaluated from the grain area",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Limiting size distribution, 27 sputter-deposited Al and Cu films (Barmak et al. 2013)",
      "value": "lognormal, sigma = 0.5, mu = -0.12",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "p. 1; Fig. 1 caption, p. 2",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Growth exponent of the same experiments",
      "value": "n ~ 1/2",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "p. 1",
      "note": "<R> = k t^n",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Grain size variable",
      "value": "R = equivalent radius computed from the grain area; <R> = arithmetic average over all grains",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Fig. 1 caption, p. 2",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Hillert 2D distribution",
      "value": "p(x) = (2e)^2 2x/(2 - x)^4 exp(-4/(2 - x))",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "eq. (2), p. 2",
      "note": "free of adjustable parameters (Fig. 1 caption)",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Weibull form",
      "value": "p(x) = (beta/alpha) (x/alpha)^(beta - 1) exp{-(x/alpha)^beta}",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "eq. (3), p. 2",
      "note": "Rayleigh: beta = 2",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Rayleigh fit to the experiment",
      "value": "alpha = 1.030, beta = 2",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "eq. (3), p. 2; Fig. 1 caption, p. 2",
      "note": "mean of the fitted curve alpha*Gamma(1.5) = 0.913 (computed here)",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Weibull fit to the experiment",
      "value": "alpha = 1.001, beta = 2.367",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "eq. (3), p. 2; Fig. 1 caption, p. 2",
      "note": "mean of the fitted curve alpha*Gamma(1 + 1/beta) = 0.887 (computed here)",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "2D simulations (Potts, multi-phase-field, orientation-field, Mullins-type) against the experiment",
      "value": "consistent with each other, fit reasonably well to the Weibull type, significantly differ from the experimental lognormal",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "p. 3; Fig. 2, p. 2",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Potts model results",
      "value": "Q = 32 Potts: fair agreement with Hillert; a later Q = 72 Potts study: substantially different distribution",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "pp. 2-3",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2017",
      "quantity": "Total variation distance between the distributions fitted at two steady-state times",
      "value": "delta_T = 0.020 (HMP) and 0.011 (KWC), lognormal fits; 0.020 (HMP) and 0.031 (KWC), Weibull fits",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Appendix II, p. 11 and p. 12",
      "note": "delta_T = 1/2 integral |p_t1(x) - p_t2(x)| dx",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2019",
      "quantity": "Reduced equivalent diameter, experiment (35000 grains set)",
      "value": "lognormal, mu = -0.12, sigma = 0.49 (fit reduced average 1.001)",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Table 1, p. 7",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2019",
      "quantity": "Reduced equivalent diameter, experiment (3700 grains subset)",
      "value": "lognormal, mu = -0.15, sigma = 0.57 (fit reduced average 1.012)",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Table 1, p. 7",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2019",
      "quantity": "Reduced equivalent diameter, Mullins model",
      "value": "normal, mean 1.00, s.d. 0.38",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Table 1, p. 7",
      "note": "not comparable with lognormal parameters (Table 1 caption)",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2019",
      "quantity": "Experiment",
      "value": "Al thin films, sputter deposition, annealed at 400 C, TEM, boundaries traced by hand; the 35000-grain set also included Cu films",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Sect. 2.1, pp. 3-4",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2019",
      "quantity": "Grains on the domain boundary",
      "value": "excluded from the analysis",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Sect. 2, p. 3",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2019",
      "quantity": "Small and large grains",
      "value": "experiment and PFC show a small-grain \"ear\" and a large-grain \"tail\"; Mullins diameters almost normal",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Sect. 3.1, p. 7",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2019",
      "quantity": "Number of sides",
      "value": "side class = number of neighbours; experiment closer to Mullins than to PFC; experiment and PFC peak at 5",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Sect. 3.4, pp. 9-10",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2019",
      "quantity": "Aboav-Weaire form",
      "value": "m(N) = 5 + 8/N; the Mullins model matches it quite well",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Sect. 3.4, p. 10",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-2019",
      "quantity": "Mullins model data",
      "value": "isotropic threshold dynamics, periodic square domain, 11910 final grains",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "Sect. 2.3, p. 6",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-1988",
      "quantity": "von Neumann-Mullins law",
      "value": "dA/dt = (pi/3) M (n - 6)",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "eq. (2), p. 1697",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-1988",
      "quantity": "Grain size",
      "value": "R = (A/pi)^(1/2)",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "p. 1699",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-1988",
      "quantity": "Perimeter rule",
      "value": "R(n) = (1/4)(n - 2) R",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "eq. (7), p. 1700",
      "note": "R(n) = average size of an n-sided grain",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-1988",
      "quantity": "Aboav-Weaire rule",
      "value": "v(n) = 5 + (6 + mu)/n, mu = <(n - 6)^2>",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "eq. (8), p. 1700",
      "note": "mu called the variance of the number-of-sides distribution",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-1988",
      "quantity": "Lattice models",
      "value": "scaling requires a mean grain size much larger than the lattice constant",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "p. 1700",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S-STAT-1988",
      "quantity": "Early lattice simulations",
      "value": "alpha = 0.41 +/- 0.02 with R <~ 10 lattice constants; crossover to alpha = 1/2 at late times on larger lattices",
      "unit": "",
      "location": "pp. 1700-1701",
      "note": "",
      "verdict": "confirmed"
    }
  ],
  "MATLAB": "24.2.0.2712019 (R2024b)"
}